weirdskyfan64 wrote:
I was the gunsmith, so I had armed Martial just for the eck' of it on the first day. Since it was the only avenue we had, I pursued it- but ultimately led OZ on a wild goose chase through mounds of red tape, all of my own doing.
Sorry.
No problems, I know exactly what it's like. In the other game I played previously, I thought that I had the whole game figured out and made tonnes of mistakes and even accused the main townie of being part of the mafia! I'd be a total hypocrite to blame you for any of that when I've done far worse before.
I thought that there was one mafia member too much for the game. One less and it could have been a lot more open. On the other side, the low amount of total members made it very luck based since the first shot has to hit. Guess I should have participated eventhough I don't really have time for it just for the sake of another town member.
I think the first two days were horribly played from the town. Lynching nobody was imo a bad decision since that way you don't get any information. The starting point to many suspicions are the bandwagons of votes. It is better to lynch a town member after some discussions at the start than agreeing silently to not vote anybody. Otherwise, you don't even have a chance to find a mafia member and start the game on the third day without any further information. Because let's be honest: The info which member got killed isn't worth much without any prior actions.
Personally, I'd prefer to lynch someone who would likely not help the town too much by only lurking around (in previous rounds)
Also: Sending PMs should be forbidden as the communication should happen in the thread.
@weirdskyfan - you (gunsmith), OZ (detective) and Martial (Doctor)
@OZ - Great observations there and a nice summary from the detective's POV. Thanks for your input, something to learn for whoever runs this next!
@SSJ2 - A good time to watch the chatzy
@Paul - by a fluke, though I did think you jumped to conclusions waaaaay to quickly, but by a twist of fate it was the right one
@knockout - Thanks for your input, I'll take it onboard if I run the next version! Thanks for the PM thing as well, next time I'd say the Mason's are allowed to though, as its kind of the point of their role. And yes, not great tactics from the town
Who'd be interested in another game in about a week? I'll open up sign-ups soon, so shout out or put a zabel on the post (jdog you like hunter ) if you're interested. Advice after our discussion at the end of this one, publicly or PM, wouldn't be amiss either!
24/02/21 - kandesbunzler said “I don't drink famous people."
15/08/22 - SotD said "Your [jandal's] humour is overrated"
11/06/24 - knockout said "Winning is fine I guess. Truth be told this felt completely unimportant." [PT] Xero Racing
